Religion and Suicides in Medieval Germany

Each dot on this graph represents a province and has two associated numbers: the percentage of the inhabitants who were Protestants and the suicide rate.
 
Here are different ways to describe the association in this data:
  1. Provinces with a higher percentage of Protestants [tend to] have a higher suicide rate.
  2. As the percentage of Protestants increases, the suicide rate increases.
  3. Protestants are more likely to commit suicide than Catholics.
  4. A person who is Protestant is more likely to commit suicide than if he/she was Catholic.
Answer the following questions:
Each dot on this graph represents a province and has two associated numbers: the percentage of the inhabitants who were Protestants and the suicide rate.
 
Here are different ways to describe the association in this data:
  1. Provinces with a higher percentage of Protestants [tend to] have a higher suicide rate.
  2. As the percentage of Protestants increases, the suicide rate increases.
  3. Protestants are more likely to commit suicide than Catholics.
  4. A person who is Protestant is more likely to commit suicide than if he/she was Catholic.
Answer the following questions:
Are all the claims the same?
Yes
No
What purpose does each claim have? Which of these claims are supported by data? What information would be needed to make unsupported claims true?
Descriptive/Associative
Causal
Predictive
Supported by Data
1.
2.
3.
4.
{"name":"Religion and Suicides in Medieval Germany", "url":"https://www.supersurvey.com/QPREVIEW","txt":"Each dot on this graph represents a province and has two associated numbers: the percentage of the inhabitants who were Protestants and the suicide rate.   Here are different ways to describe the association in this data: Provinces with a higher percentage of Protestants [tend to] have a higher suicide rate. As the percentage of Protestants increases, the suicide rate increases. Protestants are more likely to commit suicide than Catholics. A person who is Protestant is more likely to commit suicide than if he\/she was Catholic. Answer the following questions:, Are all the claims the same?","img":"https://www.supersurvey.com/3012/CDN/81-3827748/protestants.png?sz=1200-00000000001000005300"}
Make your own Survey
- it's free to start.